About the ShowTour DatesGroup DiscountsOur CastEmail/Text ClubAbout UsContact UsBear Lake Info
Get Tix
This Digital Playbill only works on Mobile Devices in Portriat Mode.
 All Cast
Cary Youmans
Santa/Teller
Cary Youmans is always thrilled to personify Santa in a Pickleville Christmas musical! He recently retired from USU’s Caine College of the Arts as the music major academic advisor, and just finished a two-month contract training cast-mate Nathan Scott as his successor. Cary now faces figuring out how to balance his life between his spouse and their two cats, Breezy and Bunny, (aka “Biddy” and “Baby Kitten”), directing the choir at Prince of Peace Lutheran Church in Logan, UT, and his hobbies of model trains and model kit building.
Jolly Tidbits

What’s your favorite Christmas movie?

Scrooge (Leslie Bricusse musical starring Albert Finney)

What’s a Christmas song you never get tired of?

Some Children See Him

What’s a Christmas song you could do without (ie not exactly your favorite)?

Baby It’s Cold Outside

Tell us about a funny or embarrassing stage-related experience you’ve had.

My first high school play included lighting effects for the sun, moon, and lightening. White performing my lines in one of the early performances, I noticed some frantic activity by the lighting crew. Shortly after that, I noticed all three effects, sun, moon, and lightening, on at the same time, hanging in the backdrop sky like some apocalyptic omen.

What’s one thing that’s on YOUR Christmas wish-list this year?

The prioritization of meaning over things and fulfillment over profit.

Fun Fact

Cary hosts an annual “Train Play Day” every second Saturday in December. It is an open house for all ages to come play with his 1950’s vintage American Flyer trains and accessories, as well as the Polar Express, the Hogwarts Express, and Thomas the Tank Engine. If interested, you can find details on my FB and Instagram pages.

Shout Out

Shout out to my husband Reid for his putting up (“patience” is not precisely the right word) with my hobbies and involvement with theatre. Also, to TJ for inviting me back this year.

Past Credits

Tevye in Fiddler on the Roof (Music Theatre West)

Col. Pickering in My Fair Lady (Music Theatre West)

Selsdon Mowbry in Noises Off (Cache Theatre Company)

Shylock in Something Rotten (MTW/CTC)

J.P. Morgan in Ragtime (Cache Theatre Company)

Prof. Porter in Tarzan (Four Seasons Theatre Company)

Mr. Jacobi/Mayor in Newsies (Utah Festival Opera and Musical Theatre)

Park Keeper in Mary Poppins (Utah Festival Opera and Musical Theatre)

©2025 Pickleville Enterprises • All Awesomeness Reserved